Data and Decisions
Many mission-driven leaders treat data strictly as a tool for backward-looking funder reports rather than a practical guide for planning future projects and initiatives. In this session, data strategy consultant Bree Taylor shares simple, approachable ways to build comfort with existing information and make confident decisions even when datasets are messy or incomplete.
What You'll Learn
In this session, you’ll learn:
How to bridge the gap between collecting data and taking action by starting small and testing assumptions you already hold.
Simple techniques for shifting from backward-looking compliance reporting to forward-looking trend analysis using existing reports.
Why pairing bite-sized quantitative metrics with qualitative community feedback and staff observations leads to stronger, human-centered decisions.
Key Timestamps:
00:00 - Introduction
02:02 - Bridging the Disconnect Between Data Collection and Action
05:00 - Shifting from Backward-Looking Reports to Forward-Looking Decisions
10:40 - Making Confident Decisions with Messy Data and Qualitative Insights
Building Data Confidence Through Simple Habits
The biggest barrier preventing nonprofits from using data effectively is rarely a lack of sophisticated software, but rather a lack of time and comfort with analyzing information. Instead of waiting for an elaborate database or complex spreadsheet system, leaders can build momentum by reviewing existing reports side by side to spot multi-year trends. Testing simple, everyday assumptions—such as verifying where donations originate or tracking basic participation shifts—helps teams become familiar with finding and interpreting evidence. Starting with small, manageable questions transforms data from an intimidating chore into a practical, reliable foundation for project planning.
Balancing Numbers with Human-Centered Qualitative Insight
Mission-driven organizations rarely have pristine, complete datasets, yet leaders still have to make high-stakes operational decisions. Focusing on a single, bite-sized data subset tied directly to an immediate organizational priority allows teams to clean and evaluate information without getting bogged down. Equally important is recognizing that quantitative numbers never tell the full story; staff observations, community conversations, and qualitative survey feedback provide vital context that spreadsheets cannot capture. Filtering numerical trends through human expertise ensures that organizational decisions remain grounded, accurate, and aligned with real community needs.
Move From Insight to Action
Ready to move your projects and plans forward with more clarity and confidence? Let's Connect to explore the support your organization needs, or learn more about Our Approach to turning strategy into action.
Full Episode Transcript
Prefer to read or search the content? Below is the full transcript from this session. Note: Transcripts are lightly formatted for readability.
All right, welcome everybody to our impactful projects and planning series. I am Jami Yazdani. I'm really excited to be here today with Bree Taylor to talk about ways nonprofits can use data to drive better decision making. So, Bree is the founder of Atrica, a data strategy and impact analytics consultancy that helps mission-driven organizations turn information into evidence that they can trust. So, welcome, Bree. Great to have you.
Thank you for having me.
Yeah. So, tell us a little bit about your work and your business, and and you know what impact you're trying to create for your clients.
Yeah, I help nonprofits use their data to understand their communities and decide where to focus their efforts. A lot of times, this looks like helping them to clean, analyze, and report their data. And the impact I hope to have is to help them have a basis for making decisions, so they're not just taking a guess at things. Something they can use to make a concrete plan. Wonderful.
Yeah, I um, you know, often people think about project management as just timelines and things, but in my work with clients, I see decision making is often a difficult point. First of all, deciding to even do a project, whether they've decided to sort of do the correct project, and then also, you know, decision making often holds up projects, it delays them, and people don't have a plan for it. And so I'm I'm excited to have this conversation with you because of that because I think decision making sometimes kind of becomes that thing that we just assume will happen and oh we've got data so we can make make decisions that nonprofits collect a massive amount of particularly donor and program data, but folks often feel overwhelmed with trying to use it. So, where are you seeing the biggest disconnect between having data and actually making decisions?
Yeah, I think it's that transition part between the collecting the data and moving to the decision making, and the the disconnect, the the piece in between there is really the analyzing the data or viewing it. That's what gets you from one step to the next. And the tricky part is this takes time. There's a learning curve to just get comfortable with it. And so, for organizations or leaders just getting started, I'd say review your data to like test what you already know. Let's say you already know that most of your donations come from first-time donors. Just go look at your donor data and confirm that. And the worst thing that can happen is you're surprised, and then you start exploring the data and learn something new.
Yeah, I love that suggestion to kind of start with maybe the assumptions that that you're making and whether the data actually bears it out, and then you know kind of reacting based on on that, and so you know that disconnect. You know, I often see it too because a lot of systems supply a lot of data, and it is it you know it's sort of an overwhelming amount often that that we have, and then yeah, people are sort of too busy to to dive into it. But I think making that that time, and I yeah,
I think what's really key there is it's great if you actually get an insight and you make a decision. But what I really would encourage people to do is just become comfortable with the data is what I'm saying. It's okay if you are more than once, you know, asking a question that you already know and just reviewing it. You're becoming confident with finding that data, learning how to interpret it, and again, worst case scenario, you can use it to make a decision.
Yeah, no, that's a. I mean, I think that confidence piece is really important because I do think that often plays, particularly with leaders, but even sort of further down the the chain with anyone sort of doing work. That often, you know, we want to be confident in in making decisions, and you know, kind of imposter syndrome and all of those other things that can come up, and so yeah, if the data can back up what you, you know, feel like you've been seeing, and then too, when you if and when you do have to make a decision, you kind of have something to point to. So most nonprofits use. And often this is what they're asked to do, but they use data to report on what they've already done. So maybe to a funder, out to to donors or the board. So what shifts can a leader make to start using data to make decisions about what to do next or when you know kind of considering or planning a project or initiative.
Yeah, I say if you're already collecting that data and reporting it out, like what already happened, that's a great place to start. Take those reports and put them side by side and see what's changing over time. So you're finding a trend. So if you were reporting every year how many people you served and what services they use, if you have that data for the past five years, like just put it side by side and like look at what changed. How did the you know how did that happen? How did the trend go up or down? How did the the number of people you served increase or decrease? And again, more than likely, the leaders and the people involved, you know the answer. But once again, this is the exploration of if you do find something that you don't have an answer to, that's a great priestess to start working with your data and Using it to to drive decisions.
Yeah. So you know we've only been talking for a couple of minutes, but a couple of times you've said the word comfort, and so you know is it sounds like you know which I think maybe might not be a surprise to folks, but a lot of people sort of aren't comfortable with data and spreadsheets. And so, what role do you think comfort kind of plays in the way people are approaching data?
Yeah, I think it's I think it's a huge barrier, and maybe it's not at the front of people's mind that they're not comfortable or confident with it, but we are we're constantly analyzing and looking at data throughout our lives, right? So it's maybe it's not so much that we're not comfortable with it, but I encourage you to find ways to confirm for yourself, I guess, that you are using data, you are making decisions. Yeah, I think that's a that's a real barrier in understanding, and that helps to the other part. I see is people not, I guess, seeing the value there. Once you're confident and you're looking at it, and you see again, even if you didn't gain an insight, but you see how this data is tied to the decision you want to make, you start to better understand where I guess the gold nuggets could be in your data. What's what's valuable insights?
Yeah, I think I I really like that because I do think sometimes we approach things like using data in sort of an all or nothing, you know. And people are often thinking about it when they're doing a big system implementation or something. But it doesn't have to be a huge, a huge thing. Like you said, you could just look at the last couple of years of reports to the board or to donors or whatever, and and see you know kind of what the trends are, and and often confirm kind of what you already know, and I would imagine too that you know when folks are are doing reports for grants and things like that, and they might be different programs. There still might be some kind of pieces of data there that that really kind of align, and sort of thinking about it that way, rather than you know having to have some huge data.
Yeah, and I want to be clear that it it doesn't have to be a big plan, and it doesn't have to be some elaborate like database or even a spreadsheet. Like if you're seeing like people have on their websites, like how many people they serve. Like even if you're just capturing it there and writing it on a whiteboard or a piece of paper, and just literally like putting the numbers side by side. You don't have to make a chart out of it. You don't have to make a graph. Just put the numbers side by side and say, "Hey, this keeps going up. It's there." It'd be easy to see like, "Hey, this keeps increasing by double fold." It'd be easy for you to understand this is increasing 10%, so yeah, it doesn't have to be anything super technical,
right? Yeah, you don't have to create a pivot table in Excel to to use the data, right? So, so yeah, that's a that's a really I think a great point for people because I do think well, and I find this with with projects sometimes or planning that people feel like you have to do this huge thing, and those are the only things that deserve attention. But little improvements, you know, one or two small things, first of all, helps you, like you said, build confidence. But also, those are start. Starting points. We don't, you know, we you don't need to run first. Yeah, yeah, the marathon. You just need to take a, you know, a short walk around the block or something.
That's it. And it'll grow naturally the same way. You'll just want to walk more. You'll get to a point where you're just putting it on the whiteboard and you're like, I wish I could see more of this. You'll get to a point where you want to use a tool or a system to see more. So I think that's a great analogy.
Well, and I also imagine too that at that point, if you start small, you may be able to see places where you wish you had more data, and then you know you can think about collecting that. So kind of related to that, nonprofits rarely sort of have perfect or complete data sets, and so how can leaders make you know confident decisions, high stakes decisions when they feel like their their data is sort of messy or partial? What advice do you have?
Yeah, I think I would start with getting a little specific first. So, tying a question directly to your organization's current priority is a good start. So, what we're doing there is identifying a question that is going to, you know, go in the right direction, and I take that question to whoever on your team is like the data person, like helps with data, and from there you can find a data set or a portion of your data that is related to that question, but also bite-sized enough that you can increase the quality of it before making a decision. So that messier partial data, you know, let's say you have, you know, dozens of spreadsheets, and you know, there's there's a lot to take on. I'm saying just step back, just ask one question, make sure it's you know tied to what you're focusing on right now, and just go find that data set that you can improve and make that decision. From there, you want to keep on with the practice of improving the data, so it's not like all hands on or like a last minute thing to do that. But I really like this question because it's even if you don't have the capacity to do that, kind of like we were saying before. There's other data. There's qualitative data. You can use what you're seeing. What are the what is your community telling you? What are what is what are your staff or volunteers saying, "What are you observing?" That's data. Not all data is numbers. And I would say, if I had to make an important decision, and like I said, I didn't. I don't have the capacity to fix this messy data. Use use other data. Use the surveys that people are filling out. If you have exit interviews, or you know whatever is available, and these these could be conversations where I'm saying like what what is your staff saying or what are your community saying. It could be in a form and a survey they took, but it could be conversational. It could be you seeing that participation is just decreasing. That's just observation. You're just seeing that, but that's data that you can really use to start driving driving decisions.
Yeah, no, that's. I think it's what I often see when people try to make decisions, particularly in nonprofits, is we want to have a lot of different input, right? And the data is is input. It's not the decision, right? And so you use what you've got, you use what you can access. But often we're trying to bring other people into those decisions, and sometimes those other people do want to see the data as you know, as much as as they can, or they want to look at some numbers, or they want to look like you said at qualitative. I do think qualitative often, you know, gets gets maybe a bad reputation as not not being as valid. And I, but you know, for people centered organizations, don't we sort of want to hear you know kind of from people, whether they're our users or or our team, and so yeah, I think I often see when I'm doing strategic planning, this you know push like we have to have a KPI you know assigned to like a quantitative measure assigned to something, and sometimes it's like we painted the you know teen room or whatever. Like that's a yes or no. It doesn't have to be you know that the like I you know. And I'm a fan of having good good measurement and things like that. But I think sometimes we're you know making things overly. Complicated and you know, and I think sometimes there's a push to have quantitative data be like the the top thing that we're considering when there's a lot of other information that we can be getting, and also you know, in most nonprofits, a lot of the folks working there are experts and their expertise in even looking at the data and kind of comparing it to what they know and what they're seeing and what they're hearing from people, you know, I think those are are just as as valuable. Yep,
I agree. Go ahead, please, please.
I was just going to say I agree 100%, and I don't land in the camp of people of like that the numbers rule everything. I'll even push to say that the human-centered view and the qualitative, in most cases, it might be more important because if your data, if you have real numbers that tell you a thing, but you know by observation that something is different is happening. That doesn't make the data wrong or bad, but you should be including that perspective. One, you probably need to continue exploring the data, or you've made an assumption about the data. But nonetheless, if you're at a meeting, the data says one thing, but we've observed other things. We're seeing that that should, in a way, supersede the data. It should either make you pause and go back and you know revalidate with the data, or numbers can't show everything, right? And so I think I said before that you can observe like the attendance decreasing, right? But numbers can't show you people's expression. Like if you have attendance and people are not paying attention, and maybe they're, you know, on their phone. Like numbers can't show you that. Numbers can't show you everything. So I'm 100% in line with you as a data professional. I would never say we put the numbers in front of the the human the human part of it,
right? Well, and humans are interpreting the data. I mean, maybe you can put it in AI and let it it tell you something, but hopefully you're questioning that, and you know, as it says in the bottom to to confirm whatever it's telling you. So yeah, I mean, humans are interpreting the data, and I I do think I mean I think attendance numbers are a great example of, you know, if you're just offering a program and and counting how many people showed up, that says nothing about whether they enjoyed it, whether they stayed the whole time, whether they keep coming back, and those are data points that you could start collecting, but you don't know until you kind of run it through a human filter. So great, thank you so much. What is the best way for folks to to reach out to you if if they want help with with data and the work we do, the
simplest way would be on LinkedIn retailer or email me at info@attrica.co, and so that's c o not c o m.co.
Okay, great, and we can put that in the the comments underneath the video as well. So wonderful. So thanks, everybody. Thank you for participating in our series. Thanks, thanks, Bree. I do take December off, and so these these series. Well, I don't take the whole month off, but I take it off from doing these these series, and so I'll be back in January. So thanks, everybody. We'll see you next time.
Thanks again for having me. This was fun.
Yeah. Thank you.